Site icon Catanduanes Tribune

2025 Annual Audit Report:

COA flags 15 unimplemented, unutilized projects in Caramoran

An audit of the Caramoran municipal government’s 2025 transactions and projects showed that 13 development projects remained unimplemented as of yearend and two infrastructure projects were unutilized months after their supposed completion.

The Commission on Audit stated in its report that out of the 63 priority development projects funded by the 20% Development Fund (DF) from current and continuing appropriations totaling P59.36 million, 13 projects costing P11.2 million were not implemented while five projects costing P11 million were still ongoing as of Dec. 31, 2025.

Among the unimplemented projects were: Construction of Reservoir at Datag West, P300,000; Construction of Steel Gate with Service Door and Lighting (MRF and Warehouse) at Baybay, P500,000; Construction of Flood Control at Tubli, P1 million; Installation of 100-liter Stainless Water Tank with Stand including Plumbing at MRF at Baybay, P400,000; Construction of Sanitary Toilet at MRF and Warehouse at Baybay, P300,000; Construction of Retaining Wall at Sabangan, P1 million; and Construction of Day Care Center (Light Materials) at Salvacion, P335,227.28.

Six projects – Purchase of Truck for Hakot Eskwela (P4.5 million) Construction of Sanitary Landfill at Baybay (P10.5 million), Improvement of Water System at Hitoma (P1 million) and Purchase of Lot at Bocon (P1 million); Construction of Drainage Canal from Tubli to Bagong Barrio – were not implemented as their respective funding allocations were realigned by the Sangguniang Bayan.

The report stated that the landfill project did not push through due to the pending assessment of the site by the Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB) while the P1-million appropriation for the lot purchase in Bocon failed due to unavailability of land.

On the other hand, the funds for the Hakot Eskwela truck had to be utilized in the immediate repair of the Materials Recovery Facility (MRF) and warehouse.

“Recurring re-alignment and renaming of original PPAs during the implementation year, due to projects not being feasible and implementation-ready, resulted in delays and inefficiencies in the utilization of appropriated funds,” the audit team observed, adding that these conditions show deficiencies in the planning and prioritization process of the Municipal Development Council (MDC).

The audit also found that two completed projects totaling P5.69 million funded under the 20% DF were not utilized as of the time of inspection, depriving intended beneficiaries of the benefits and increasing the risk of wastage of government funds.

The Construction of Water System in Sabangan costing nearly P1 million was completed on March 20, 2025 but was not operational 11 months later on February 2026 when the audit team traveled to the village.

An interview with barangay officials stated that the water system was not utilized due to the absence of distribution pipes connecting the reservoir to the tap stands in the residential areas.

The barangay council had to allocate funding in their own budget for the distribution line.

The audit team said this indicates lapses in planning and cost estimation, as the MDC was unable to ensure that the allocated fund of P1 million was sufficient for the project’s completion.

“The prolonged non-utilization from completion of the original project up to the extended completion of the installation of the distribution pipelines, which is approximately two years, is tantamount to wastage of government funds, as the public fund spent on this project did not immediately provide the intended public service and benefits to the community,” the COA stressed.

Another project, the construction of the P4.7 million one-storey building for the Municipal Tourism Office, Local Youth Development Office, and the Senior Citizen/PWD Office was supposedly completed on June 24, 2025 but was still unused to the lack of power and water connections.

At the time of the audit, municipal officials said no go signal had been given by the mayor for the offices to transfer to and occupy the building, which had already remained idle for nine months.

The management explained that the delayed energization of the building was due to the decision to defer the application for electric service pending completion of the adjacent public terminal and public market.

Meanwhile, various defects and damages were found on some infrastructure projects, with no action from the contractor supposed to undertake repair works as part of the warranty.

The audit team listed a total of 11 projects with such defects, including the damaged roofing at the MRF and motor pool, cracks and peeling paint at several buildings, and scaling of concrete floors.

It urged the local chief executive to require the OIC-Municipal Engineer to demand immediate rectification of the defects from the concerned contractor.

A report from the General Services Office also showed that of the nine two-wheeled vehicles owned by the LGU, four had no available copy of certificate of registration and three of five registered motorcycles had expired registrations since 2019.

Of the eight (8) four-wheeled vehicles, five have expired registrations and the ownership of three of them have yet to be transferred to the LGU while the donation of a multicab to barangay Sabangan has yet to be formally completed.

The team also remarked that some of the vehicles procured by the municipality were not marked with the name of the agency and “For Official Use Only” as required under Section V(2) of COA Circular No. 75-6.

Exit mobile version